• We are now running on a new, and hopefully much-improved, server. In addition we are also on new forum software. Any move entails a lot of technical details and I suspect we will encounter a few issues as the new server goes live. Please be patient with us. It will be worth it! :) Please help by posting all issues here.
  • The forum will be down for about an hour this weekend for maintenance. I apologize for the inconvenience.
  • If you are having trouble seeing the forum then you may need to clear your browser's DNS cache. Click here for instructions on how to do that
  • Please review the Forum Rules frequently as we are constantly trying to improve the forum for our members and visitors.

1911 vs. G20 vs. G34

Primus

Regular Member
Joined
Oct 24, 2013
Messages
3,939
Location
United States
1911 vs. G23 vs. G34

Alright boys and girls.... was feeling frisky tonight and figured I'd some "tests" tonight at the range. This test was conducted at a local indoor range. Temp was a moderate 65ish. No idea about humidity. All shots were from the same stance and "style" or lack there of (isosceles, two handed, strong hand). Distance was at 25FT and 50 FT +or - a few inches. So.... here's the guns...

1911- Auto Ordnance in .45 cal
G34- 9mm ( "full size" )
G23- .40 cal ( medium size )

Ammo-
All 1911 was in Hornady Critical Defense JHP 185 GR
G34 was half in Aguilla 9mm 124 GR FMJ and half in some left over stuff from who knows were. It was shiny and 9mm. See disclaimer at bottom.
G23 was half in Remington 180GR JHP and half was 155GR American Eagle FMJ.

So... Here's some photos and results hopefully...

First... 1911 dun dun dun dun dun.....


The middle two photos are from the 50 FT mark.

Pros- Accurate. Recoil is minor due to firearm weight/design. First RD is SA.

Cons- Not used to the trigger. More operator error then Gun. Not used to take up until stop, then having to "yank" the trigger to get it to go. This is a MA compliant model so the good old cave man 10 lb trigger. Get a trigger job if/when you get one of these.



NOTE= ALL TARGETS WERE A 5 1/2 IN BULLS EYE TARGET. THE PIECE OF PAPER IS 8 1/2 BY ABOUT 12.
 

Attachments

  • AO 1911 .45 Horn CD 185GR 25FT 8RD.jpg
    AO 1911 .45 Horn CD 185GR 25FT 8RD.jpg
    92.2 KB · Views: 222
  • AO 1911 .45 Horn CD 185GR JHP 50FT 8rd.jpg
    AO 1911 .45 Horn CD 185GR JHP 50FT 8rd.jpg
    93.2 KB · Views: 176
  • AO 1911 .45 Horn. CD 185GR 50FT 8RD.jpg
    AO 1911 .45 Horn. CD 185GR 50FT 8RD.jpg
    92.2 KB · Views: 164
  • AO 1911 .45 Horn. CD 185GR JHP 25FT 8RD.jpg
    AO 1911 .45 Horn. CD 185GR JHP 25FT 8RD.jpg
    94.9 KB · Views: 237
Last edited:

Primus

Regular Member
Joined
Oct 24, 2013
Messages
3,939
Location
United States
G34

Next G34.....

G34 9mm 50FT 10RD.jpgG34  50FT 10 RD.jpgG34 9mm Aguilla 124GR 25FT 10RD (2).jpgG34 9mm Aguilla 124GR 25FT 10RD.jpg

Glocks run like.... Glocks. They all seem to be the same. From a baby Glock up to these full size "tactical" Glocks. The trigger is.... unique lets say. I've grown accustomed to it, simply because I'm a Glock guy. Try one before you buy it.

The first half of photos 1,2 were using some ammo that I found in my safe in a ammo case, can't remember who makes it or what the weights were. The second set are using Aguilla Ammo 134 GR. No issues.
 
Last edited:

Primus

Regular Member
Joined
Oct 24, 2013
Messages
3,939
Location
United States
G23

G23.... half with JHP and half with FMJ

G23 155GR FMJ Ame. Eagle 25FT 10RD.jpgG23 155GR FMJ Ame. Eagle 50FT 10RD.jpgG23 180GR Rem. JHP  25FT 10RD.jpgG23 180GR Rem. JHP 50FT 10RD.jpg

G23... good old .40. This is my carry gun.

The photos are set up with the American Eagle ammo first, 25FT then 50ft. Then the Rem. JHP stuff at 25 FT and 50 FT. This is my favorite gun, but it's because I carry it for work, carry it off duty, and shoot it in competitions. So I am biased.
 
Last edited:

Primus

Regular Member
Joined
Oct 24, 2013
Messages
3,939
Location
United States
Disclaimer...

1) I'm not a friggin scientist. So there's NOTHING scientific about the above "tests".
2) I'm not a gun guru. I just shoot alot. There is definitely operator error in some of those shot groups. This was basically 1 continuous test with no rest breaks, so yea by the end there was a bit of fatigue from trying to hit a bulls eye at 50 friggin FT.
3) This isn't an endorsement or "write up" from a magazine or an "expert". This is a guy who shoots alot who figured I'd share some photos of what I can do with these guns. I'll gladly answer any questions about these firearms or this range session.
4) Yea.... I'm an idiot. The Thread Title has a typo that I can't fix. It says G20 as opposed to G23. Good thing I turned down that NASA job :)
 
Last edited:

Rusty Young Man

Regular Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2013
Messages
1,548
Location
Árida Zona
Well, you seem to transition better between the angles at which you cant the guns (1911 vs Glocks). There are some things (like said angle) I just don't like about Glocks and other Glock-tastic guns, but accuracy and reliability aren't on that list.

Also, I doubt people will try to make this a "scientific accuracy" thread. Seeing as we OC for self defense, I think people will realize that humidity, wind speed and direction, lighting, and the position of the moon are all up to the whims of the cosmos.:p

Nice pictures, by the way. Any chance we can have photos of the guns?
 
Last edited:

WalkingWolf

Regular Member
Joined
Jul 31, 2011
Messages
11,912
Location
North Carolina
The position of the moon is very accurate. Unless it is not the moon that rotates the earth, such as a personal moon.:p
 

Firearms Iinstuctor

Regular Member
Joined
Jul 12, 2011
Messages
3,358
Location
northern wis
Your tests are relevant to you and are interesting.

But translating them to others is a hard line to pull.

Glad you enjoyed doing them done many like them myself it is always good to know how's ones own pistols shoot and handle.

The practice never hurts.
 

OC for ME

Regular Member
Joined
Jan 6, 2010
Messages
12,453
Location
White Oak Plantation
Do that again, but shoot the G23 first, the G34, second and then the 1911. You'll see where the fatigue component comes into play. Thanks for the info.

Side note, to save a few bucks use el cheapo WWB ammo.
 

Primus

Regular Member
Joined
Oct 24, 2013
Messages
3,939
Location
United States
Do that again, but shoot the G23 first, the G34, second and then the 1911. You'll see where the fatigue component comes into play. Thanks for the info.

Side note, to save a few bucks use el cheapo WWB ammo.

I definitely will. I did notice that I was straining with the stock sights on the 1911. Both the Gs have night sights. But different types of night sights. The 34 has a while U in white while the 23 has actual dot inlay glow sights.

I found it was tough focusing on the front sight and getting it clear while getting a sight picture at the 50 ft mark. Maybe a new front sight post is in order.

It was actually first time I had ever fired this 1911 with this trigger set up, so it was a but of curve.

I'm starting to see why guys say 1911 is the way to go for accuracy and competitions.

Sent from my XT907 using Tapatalk
 

WalkingWolf

Regular Member
Joined
Jul 31, 2011
Messages
11,912
Location
North Carolina
If Glocks had barrel bushings they would be just as accurate as a 1911. JMB designed the 1911 to lock the barrel in three places, the front bushing is integral to that locking that barrel. Many people think a tight bushing is the answer, it is not, it causes malfunction problems to use one. I never have, and get extreme accuracy with the milsurp bushing and a milsurp slide. The bushing is made loose enough to cant in the slide that cant under spring pressure not only locks the barrel but the bushing also in the slide. The barrel cannot help but return to the same position each time it is fired. From my 40 years of shooting 1911's have always found they get more accurate the more they are fired. That has to do with the wear of the bushing to the slide to match the cant to the barrel.

To see how this works take your ring and slide it onto a dowel rod and then cant the ring. It has no choice but to lock. Glock is a good gun for most people, for self defense, because they are not capable of putting a bullet directly into a eye socket. Most times my carry is with weapons I trust to give me that kind of accuracy.

If you really want to see what a 1911 will do, lock it in a ransom rest and watch it put round after round into the same hole.
 
Last edited:

OC for ME

Regular Member
Joined
Jan 6, 2010
Messages
12,453
Location
White Oak Plantation
For a standard 1911A1, ~7 pounder when loaded w/7 rounds, the first shot is the toughest one. The slide action naturally places the muzzle back on target. My experience is with the GI modle only. Those fancified Kimbers et al are high priced/over priced for a"45" in my view.

I used to demonstrate to trainees, Range Master and SA Instructor in the Navy, that the 1911A1 could be shot accurately with only a index finger and thumb. The gun would rock back and forth. I got pretty good at putting five rounds down range (@25 yds) in about 10 seconds and keep the hits within a dinner plate sized area of a B29 target, center of mass.

I've never shot a Glock, but have shot my XD. Similar? I don't know. I need more than a little switch on the trigger where mechanical safeties are concerned. I like the 1911A1 grip safety at a minimum, but thumb safety is the best safety in my view. My P90 has a decocker (thumb safety). There are some "under the hood" safety features that make my P90 the safest (in my view) gun in my house where kids are concerned. The decocker took a bit of getting used to. I'm still not used to it, and knowing it is safe to use while a round is chambered is a mental block kind of thing. It is a irrational concern, I know, but I'll deal with it.

http://www.realguns.com/archives/182.htm
 

OC for ME

Regular Member
Joined
Jan 6, 2010
Messages
12,453
Location
White Oak Plantation
For a standard 1911A1, ~7 pounder when loaded w/7 rounds, the first shot is the toughest one. The slide action naturally places the muzzle back on target. My experience is with the GI modle only. Those fancified Kimbers et al are high priced/over priced for a"45" in my view.

I used to demonstrate to trainees, Range Master and SA Instructor in the Navy, that the 1911A1 could be shot accurately with only a index finger and thumb. The gun would rock back and forth. I got pretty good at putting five rounds down range (@25 yds) in about 10 seconds and keep the hits within a dinner plate sized area of a B29 target, center of mass.

I've never shot a Glock, but have shot my XD. Similar? I don't know. I need more than a little switch on the trigger where mechanical safeties are concerned. I like the 1911A1 grip safety at a minimum, but thumb safety is the best safety in my view. My P90 has a decocker (thumb safety). There are some "under the hood" safety features that make my P90 the safest (in my view) gun in my house where kids are concerned. The decocker took a bit of getting used to. I'm still not used to it, and knowing it is safe to use while a round is chambered is a mental block kind of thing. It is a irrational concern, I know, but I'll deal with it.

http://www.realguns.com/archives/182.htm
Oh, from the linked article/review.

Both firearms are intended for law enforcement, civilian concealed carry, home defense, and recreational shooting.
The P90 is not a "civilian conceal carry" weapon, it is a "in your face Jack" (a little Uncle Si there) OC weapon. That thing is a tank, in my view, and when loaded up it is heavy, uncomfortable so. Now, if I was 6'8" or so then maybe it would feel like a good concealed carry gat.
 

OC for ME

Regular Member
Joined
Jan 6, 2010
Messages
12,453
Location
White Oak Plantation
For a standard 1911A1, ~7 pounder when loaded w/7 rounds, the first shot is the toughest one. The slide action naturally places the muzzle back on target. My experience is with the GI modle only. Those fancified Kimbers et al are high priced/over priced for a"45" in my view.

I used to demonstrate to trainees, Range Master and SA Instructor in the Navy, that the 1911A1 could be shot accurately with only a index finger and thumb. The gun would rock back and forth. I got pretty good at putting five rounds down range (@25 yds) in about 10 seconds and keep the hits within a dinner plate sized area of a B29 target, center of mass.

I've never shot a Glock, but have shot my XD. Similar? I don't know. I need more than a little switch on the trigger where mechanical safeties are concerned. I like the 1911A1 grip safety at a minimum, but thumb safety is the best safety in my view. My P90 has a decocker (thumb safety). There are some "under the hood" safety features that make my P90 the safest (in my view) gun in my house where kids are concerned. The decocker took a bit of getting used to. I'm still not used to it, and knowing it is safe to use while a round is chambered is a mental block kind of thing. It is a irrational concern, I know, but I'll deal with it.

http://www.realguns.com/archives/182.htm
Not 7 pounds, sorry 3.
 

Firearms Iinstuctor

Regular Member
Joined
Jul 12, 2011
Messages
3,358
Location
northern wis
Oh, from the linked article/review.

The P90 is not a "civilian conceal carry" weapon, it is a "in your face Jack" (a little Uncle Si there) OC weapon. That thing is a tank, in my view, and when loaded up it is heavy, uncomfortable so. Now, if I was 6'8" or so then maybe it would feel like a good concealed carry gat.

In the northern states 9 months out of the year a jacket is worn you can conceal a 1911 , P90 or full size revolver I have carried them all.

In the winter one could conceal a AR carbine if one wanted to.
 

Primus

Regular Member
Joined
Oct 24, 2013
Messages
3,939
Location
United States
In the northern states 9 months out of the year a jacket is worn you can conceal a 1911 , P90 or full size revolver I have carried them all.

In the winter one could conceal a AR carbine if one wanted to.

Do you conceal IWB? Or just regular holster with low enough hem line? If you use an IWB do you find the size and or weight an issue?

I'm tempted to start carrying the 1911

Sent from my XT907 using Tapatalk
 

Firearms Iinstuctor

Regular Member
Joined
Jul 12, 2011
Messages
3,358
Location
northern wis
Do you conceal IWB? Or just regular holster with low enough hem line? If you use an IWB do you find the size and or weight an issue?

I'm tempted to start carrying the 1911

Sent from my XT907 using Tapatalk

I only have one IWB that for 1911 but fits my HI power well also Hardly ever use it Mostly I carry my full size guns I pancake style holsters with a long enough hem line to conceal them not hard in cold or cool weather. Every now and then I well use a horizontal shoulder rig. I also have a vertical chest rig for the 7.5 inch Red Hawk I use hunting.

When carrying my 44s on my belt I wear suspenders also the weight of a Red Hawk tends to drag things down.
 

WalkingWolf

Regular Member
Joined
Jul 31, 2011
Messages
11,912
Location
North Carolina
Do you conceal IWB? Or just regular holster with low enough hem line? If you use an IWB do you find the size and or weight an issue?

I'm tempted to start carrying the 1911

Sent from my XT907 using Tapatalk

1911's are one of the most concealable full sized guns. Because they are not as thick as the double stacks they conceal very very well using a IWB holster. I carried mine shoved in my waistband behind my right hip, when working undercover, and it was very secure that way. Wearing a holster is a dead giveaway that you are a cop. Criminals do not use holsters, mostly because if they ditch a gun and are caught the holster links the gun found to them. A Star is even better because it is slimmer than the 1911. A Star BK was a popular CC gun with police in the 70's and 80's.

FI I used a pancake holster for my M39 while at the University. We were issued two holsters, a DH duty holster and a pancake.
 
Last edited:

since9

Campaign Veteran
Joined
Jan 14, 2010
Messages
6,964
Location
Colorado Springs, Colorado, USA
1911's are one of the most concealable full sized guns. Because they are not as thick as the double stacks they conceal very very well using a IWB holster.

My 9mm is full-sized and double-stacked. While it doesn't pack the punch of a .45, I do have 16+1. As it is, a double-stacked 9mm is no wider than a single-stacked .45.

Tradeoffs/

I carried mine shoved in my waistband behind my right hip, when working undercover, and it was very secure that way. Wearing a holster is a dead giveaway that you are a cop.[/qutoe]

And if you're not a cop? The most frequent question I've been asked while OC is, "Are you a cop?" I tell them "no," but as I'm not actively bringing down bad guys, it's not a detriment for those who don't ask to think I may be.
 
Top