AtackDuck
Regular Member
Ouch!
If the gun control crowd thought "Heller" was rough on them, "MacDonald" will haunt them forever. It's almost as if Alito (et al) took the shopping list of gun control law arguments and went down the line, skewering each point, then topping it off with helping of real history. I'll be reading the dissent as soon as I finish the Opinion, but I somehow think the dissent will be the usual ignoring of reality and get blown out of the water.
I'm only on page 64, but I like how scalia (starting on page 52) put the smack down on stevens.
If the gun control crowd thought "Heller" was rough on them, "MacDonald" will haunt them forever. It's almost as if Alito (et al) took the shopping list of gun control law arguments and went down the line, skewering each point, then topping it off with helping of real history. I'll be reading the dissent as soon as I finish the Opinion, but I somehow think the dissent will be the usual ignoring of reality and get blown out of the water.
Last edited: